STCG v/s Business Income

[CA.BHUPENDRASHAH]

After the introduction of Sec. 111-A having concessional rate of tax on STCG of 10%, lots of cases are decided in favour and against the assessees.
To resolve this controversy, why not a special bench?

[pawansingla]

Very difficult. There can be no hard and fast rule for that.There is lots of subjectivity involved. Facts of each case differs. No hard and fast rule can be applied.