Bangalore Electricity Supply Co. Ltd v.DCIT( 2022) 195 ITD 188 (Bang )( Trib)

S. 140 : Return by whom to be signed – Company – Appeal filed was verified by General Manager of assessee-company who did not hold a valid Power of Attorney-, Appeal was dismissed in limine [ S. 140(c), 253(6) , Rule 45(3) 47(1), ITAT R. 11. ]

The appeal filed before the Tribunal was signed by the General Manger (CT & GST ) BESCOM  . The Tribunal requested the assessee to remove the defects however the defects was not removed .  Tribunal held that Section 253(6) of the Act states that the appeal to the appellate tribunal need to be filed in the prescribed form and it is also to be verified in the prescribed manner. Meanwhile Rule 47(1) of the I.T. Rules also clarifies that “appeal shall be signed by a person specified in sub-rule (3) of Rule 45. Rule 45(3) states that the form of appeal referred to sub- rule (1) to be verified by a person who is authorized to verified by the person who is authorised to verify the return of income under section 139(1) of the Act, as applicable to the assessee. According to the provisions of section 140(c) of the Act states that in case of a company, where the appeal is to be verified by the managing director of the company or for unavoidable reason, such managing director is not able to verify the return or where there is no managing director; by any director thereof. Further, there was an amendment w.e.f. 1.4.2020 to the provisions of section 140(c) of the Act where it was stated that the return could be filed by any other person as may be prescribed for this purpose. Even if we apply this amendment retrospectively also, it is not clear whether the General Manager, (CT&GST), BESCOM was holding a valid Power of Attorney from the assessee company to verify the appeal of the assessee even as provided u/s. 140(c) of the Act. Even this information is not available on the record.  Accordingly the appeal was dismissed  in limine. ( AY. 2008 -09)