This section is now closed. Please ask your questions at our new Q&A section
Answers By Expert: Dr. K. Shivaram (Sr. Advocate)
Query

ORDER OF THE ITAT PRONOUNCED ON 04-10-2019 for the ASSESSMENT YEAR 2012-13 ITA NO 432/VIZ/2017 OPTED FOR DTVSV SCHEME FOR WAIVER OF INTEREST U/S 234(B) DATE OF FILING APPEAL BEFORE THE HIGH COURT NOT EXPIRED TILL 02-02-2021 WHETHER THE PETITIONER IS ELIGIBLE UNDER DTVSV SCHEME. NOW THE CLARIFICATION REQUIRED IS SINCE TIME FOR FILING IS NOT LAPSED AS ON 31-01-2020 (Actually 120 days from the pronouncement date 04-10-2019+ 120 days = 02-02-20 for submission in the High Court. whether he is eligible under DTVSV Scheme

Answer

The assessee has to consider the date of receipt  as date of communication as per section 260A(2) (a) of the  Act . Though the assessee has not filed the appeal the assessee is eligible for the Scheme . Refer  Circular No 9 /2020 dt 22-4 -2020   Q. No 1 and answer given by the CBDT.          

 

Query

Sir, I have received form 3 in September with net tax liability adjusted with refund adjusted till AY 2019-20.
Now on tax portal my tax refund of AY 2020-21 appears adjusted from disputed tax liability which I have opted to settle under vivad se Vishwas which is lower than the amount appearing in Form 3.
Pls advice which amount to be paid. Can I net off the tax liability for refund of AY 2020-21

Answer

Please    refer question No  Circular No. 9 /2020 dt 22 -4 2020  Q.No. 46 . Whether DA can amend his order to rectify any patent errors   . Ans . Yes , DA shall  be able to amend his order under section 5 to rectify any apparent errors . Please also  refer  CBDT  circular Q. No. 89 and answer given by the CBDT  . As per the clarification issued by the CBDT  ,Declaration filed by the CBDT can be revised any number of times before the DA issues a certificate under section 5(1) of Vivad se. Vishwas .  It may be desirable to  file rectification application before the Designated Authority .

 

Query

I have applied in vivad se vishwas scheme. My disputed tax is approx 4 lakh the payment has to be done before 30/4/2021 if not then interest will be charged. My problem is if i give half payment of 2lakh before 30/4/21 and half afterwards what will be interest percentage charge and on what amount it will be charge (the remaining amount or on the full disputed tax amount). Can i payment half amount before 30/4/21 and half after the above mentioned date

Answer

Please  refer Circular No 18 /2020 dt 28 -10 -20220 , circular in respect of payment of tax . As per the Circular the declarant can make the payment without additional amount on or before 31 St March , 2021 ( Now extended up to 30-4-2021 )     Please also refer Circular No 21 /2020 dt 4 -12 -2020.  Q.No. 87 . and Answer state that ,once the required amount of disputed penalty has been paid by the declarant  , interest relating  to such penalty would be waived . The issue being debatable the  declarant may not get the concessional rate as applicable , up to 30 -4 -2021 . The half amount paid may not be considered as required amount .   In case the assessee is not able to pay half the amount the assessee may not get the refund of the amount paid under Vsv Act . In case the Designated levies 110% of the tax in dispute on entire amount the assessee may have only  remedy of filing writ before High Court.

Query

Assessee filed Form 1 and Form 2, in respect of an appeal before Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) claiming refund of Rs.20 (say). The Designated Authority has issued Form 3 determining refund due of Rs.10(say).Before filing the Form 1 and Form 2, the assessee had moved rectification application under section 154 requesting the Assessing Officer to rectify the order passed under section 143(3). The Assessing Officer rejected the rectification application before furnishing his report to the Designated Authority. Designated Authority, while passing Form 3, stated that the Assessing Officer has rejected the rectification application, thus justifying the lower refund of Rs.10.

Answer

The Designated Authority is right in determining the refund at Rs 10 . The assessee may have to file an appeal before the CIT(A) against the rectification order  rejecting the application passed by the Assessing officer . 

Query

Pected sir
My father select se VSV scheme he has two case he also mentally ready to pay outstanding amount on or before 31st March and he also planned to arrange the Funds.

But suddenly he died on dt 16-02-2021 the text amount found in our current account and also saving account but by father’s WILL not registered as well as the witness signature is pending in WILL.

After death of my father, my father’s all accounts freezed by bank and they demanded us probeta or succession certificate from court
We consult some lawyer regarding to this matter and as per their statement certificate may be received after 6 month or 8 month.

The text amount is huge and our family can not arrange this amount.

We also request to branch level regional office level and head office level but they said that do not permit to pay the vsv scheme payment they also said that if income tax Department send any demand or attachment on this account then can release this fun
Now our family want to to fulfill my father’s liabilities as soon as possible so please give us guidance for our dues how to pay.
rksarvaiya99@gmail.com

Answer

We presume that the father has filed the  Declaration under  Vsv Act and all other  conditions of the Vsv Act is satisfied .  In case the father has given nomination in favour of any person the Bank has to transfer the amount to the nominee refer Ram Chander Talwar v. Devendra Kunar Talwar ( 2020) 10 SCC 671 . If the amount is transferred in the name of nominee , the nominee can with the consent of all legal heirs may request the bank to release the payment of tax as per VSV Act , determined by the Designated Authority .   In case the father has not given any nomination the legal heirs has to get the probate or succession Certificate .  It may be desirable to make  an application for probate or succession Certificate at the earliest and move an application before the Court to release the payment to the Income tax department . In the petition the legal heirs  can make Income tax Department as well as Bank also party as respondents . we are sure the Court may direct the Bank to release the payment in favour of the Income tax Department . In case the deceased has not filed the Vsv Declaration the legal Heirs can file the  Declaration on or before 31 st March 2021. The earlier notification dated 27 -10 -2010 has been amended  by vide Notification No. 09/2021/ F.No. IT(A)/01/2020-TPL dated 26th February, 2021 by CBDT, the time limit for payment without additional amount is extended to 30 th April 2021 . the abovementioned notification, even earlier forms issued will also be covered and payments made upto April 30, 2021 will be as per the third column of the table to section 3 of VSVA .   The assessee can also make payment after 30 th April 2021 however the assessee has to pay extra amount  . Please refer CBDT Circular No 9 dt 22-4 -2020 dt. Q No. 28 and answer given by the CBDT , it will be 110 % of the disputed tax .

 

 

 

Query

By mistake We have paid in excess of tax payable as per Form-3 of Vivad se Vishwas scheme. Can we get refund of excess amount of tax paid after filing of form-4 /

Answer

As per explanation to section 7 of VSVA, it is clarified that where the declarant had, before filing the declaration, paid any amount under the Income-tax Act in respect of his tax arrears which exceeds the amount payable under VSVA, he shall be entitled to a refund of such excess amount,  but shall not be entitled to interest on such excess amount under section 244A of the Act.  In  Nirmala L. Mehta  v. A. Balasubramanian (2004) 269 ITR 1 (Bom.)(HC)  (11) 

 “There cannot be any estoppel against the statute, Article 265 of the Constitution of India in unmistakable terms provides that no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law. Acquiescence cannot take away from a party the relief that he is entitled to where the tax is levied or collected without authority of law”. [Also refer, CIT v. V.MR.P. Firm, Muar (1965) 56  ITR 67 (74)]

CIT v. Shelly Products (2003) 261 ITR 367 (SC)  (382 )

“If the assessee has by mistake or inadvertence or on account of ignorance, included in his income any amount which is exempted from payment of Income-tax or is not income within the contemplation of law, he may like wise bring this to the notice of the assessing authority, which if satisfied, may grant him relief and refund the tax paid in excess  if any“.

 

Article. 265 of the Constitution of India reads as under ; t “No tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law“. The collection of tax has to be also within the frame work of law. The Circular No. 14 (XL-35), dt. 11/04/1955, also states that a duty is cast upon the Assessing Officer  to assist and aid the assessee in the matter of taxation. Assessing Officers  are supposed to advise the assessee and guide them and not  take advantage of any error or mistake committed by the assessee or of their ignorance. The function of the Assessing officer  is to administer the statute with solicitude for public exchequer with an inbuilt idea of fairness to taxpayers. The scope of the above circular is explained in CIT v. Ahmedabad  Keiser-E. Hind Mills Co. Ltd  (1981)  128 ITR 486 (Guj.) (HC) (492), Parekh Bros v. CIT (1984) 150 ITR 105 (Ker) (HC) (118 ),  Dattatraya Gopal Sathe v. CIT (1984) 150 ITR 460 (Bom.)(HC) (463-464)

There is no estoppel against the law , if the amount is paid in excess the assessee shall be entitle to get the refund . The assessee should write to the Designated Authority to grant the refund . In case the refund is not granted , the assessee may have to file Writ before High Court .    

 

 

Query

Dear team,

is it possible to opt vivad se viswas scheme for a case rejected with CIT (A) appeals

Answer

One of the condition is that the  pendency of Appeal before the appellate forum as on 31 -1 -2020 or pendency of deemed appeal .  Refer Circular No 9 dt 22 -4 -2020 Q .N0 1 and Answer.  Please  also refer Circular No 21 dt 4 -12-2020  Q. No. 56 and Answer. As per the circular if the appeal is disposed of by the appellate authority  , is also eligible, the amount payable under the Vivad Se Vishwas shall be computed with reference to the position of appeal or arbitration as on 31 st January , 2020.  The assessee has to  show the acknowledgement for pendency of appeal before CIT (A) as on 31 -1 -2020

 

Query

Filed F-1 and 2, received Form-3 but it was not mine but some unknown person.

Complained, 1st time, they simply resolved by saying “please look your attached Form-3”. I looked to the form-3 but it was not mine.
I again wrote in detail on 18/03/2021 to send the corrected Form-3. Till date it is not resolved. How Tax should be paid or should I wait even after 31.03.2021 to receive proper Form – 3 and then pay.
Thanks.

Answer

Please refer CBDT  Circular No. Circular No 9/2020 dt 22-4 -2020   . Q. No 46 and answer , wherein the CBDT has stated that Designated Authority shall able to amend his order under section 5 to rectify any apparent errors. The assessee may write to the Designated Authority  .   Please refer Circular No 21 /2020 dt 4-12 ,2020 , as per Q.No 89  Ans ,it has been stated that the declaration  can be revised any number of times before DA issues  a certificate under section 5(1) of the Vivad Se Vishawas. .  It may be desirable to file revised declaration .  The earlier notification dated 27 -10 -2010 has been amended  by vide Notification No. 09/2021/ F.No. IT(A)/01/2020-TPL dated 26th February, 2021 by CBDT, the time limit for payment without additional amount is extended to 30 th April 2021 . the abovementioned notification, even earlier forms issued will also be covered and payments made upto April 30, 2021 will be as per the third column of the table to section 3 of VSVA .

 

Query

Returned business loss has been converted to income and set off against brought forward business loss. Similarly addition under the head capital gains set off against brought forward unabsorbed depreciation. If we opt for VSVS , whether tax has to be paid for disputed additions

Answer

The assessee has to pay the tax on disputed additions. Please refer Circular No 9/2020 dt 22-4 -2020  Q. No. 53 and Answer given by CBDT  wherein it is stated that  to carry forward the reduced tax credit or loss or depreciation . CBDT will prescribe the manner of calculation in such cases .

 

Query

I HAVE RECEIVED FORM 3 IN RESPECT OF FORM 1 AND 2 FILED for APPEALS PENDING RELATING TO PENALTY.
WHILE MAKING PAYMENT FOR THE SAME, SHOULD I ENTER THE AMOUNT IN “PENALTY” BOX IN 280 CHALLAN UNDER CODE 400 (TAX ON REGULAR ASSESSMENT) OR IN “TAXES” BOX/ OR IN “OTHERS” BOX OF THE 280 CHALLAN.

Answer

It will be regular assessment tax challan , with minor head 400 . Write properly the PAN  NO and Assessment year . There is no separate Challan  has been prescribed .