This section is now closed. Please ask your questions at our new Q&A section
Answers By Expert: Dr. K. Shivaram (Sr. Advocate)
Query

IN THE CASE OF LONG TERM CAPITAL GAINS, IS IT NECESSARY TO GIVE SHAREWISE DETAILS FOR A.Y 2020-21?.

Answer

As per Ministry of Finance Press Release Dated, September 26, 2020, the scrip wise details in the return of income for AY 2020-21 is required to be filled up only for the reporting of the long-term capital gains for these shares/units which are eligible for the benefit of grandfathering( which was provided by the Finance Act, 2018 on gains made on the listed shares/specified units up to 31.01.2018). 

The scrip wise details are not required in income tax return forms for AY 2020-21 for computation of capital gains/business income from shares/units which are not eligible for grandfathering.

 

Query

As part of Vivad se vishwas, I have paid all my tax dues, but the IT authorities has not yet given me my form 5 even after 3 months after payment. When will the authorities give me form 5?

Answer

This is a common issue raised by other declarants and their representatives. There is a delay in responses from the Department on account of the pandemic, and Faceless Assessment/Appeals. You could wait for a reasonable time and then approach your designated authority under VSVA. 

Query

Hi Sir,

We have filed appeal on 01.02.2020. on 31.01.2020 we have tried to file appeal but due to non availability of DSC we have filed the same on 01.02.2020. now my query is can we apply for Vivad se Vishwas Scheme with a Condonation letter?

Please suggest me the best way to resolve the situation.

Thanking You, Sir

Answer

As per VSVA, to be eligible under the Scheme, an appeal or deemed appeal is required to be pending on the specified date i.e. January 31, 2020. 

If your appeal filing is delayed and a good filing would have been before the specified date; you case will be eligible under VSVA, once your application for condonation of delay is allowed.  It is desirable to approach the Appellate Authority to decide the issue of condonation of delay first . Once delay is condoned the appeal relates back  hence the assessee will be able to get the benefit of the  VSVA scheme .

Query

We have uploaded Form 4 but on portal it’s sayawaiting Form 5 what times it’s take to upload Form 5 by department

Answer

There is a delay in responses from the Department on account of the pandemic, and Faceless Assessment/Appeals. You could wait for a reasonable time and then approach your designated authority under VSVA.

Query

have filed the form 1 and form 2 online for vivad se vishwas scheme on 17th july 2020 . have already paid tax and refund has to be taken . it is more than 2 months but have not received any response from the department online. secondly appeal is pending with ITAT. do I have do withdraw the appeal or will it be withdrawn by the department.
What next should i do. Pls advise

Answer

There is a delay in responses from the Department on account of the pandemic, and Faceless Assessment/Appeals. You could wait for a reasonable time and then approach your designated authority under VSVA. 

Further, As per section 4(2) of VSVA, Upon the filing the declaration, any appeal pending before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, in respect of the disputed income or disputed interest or disputed penalty or disputed fee and tax arrear shall be deemed to have been withdrawn from the date on which certificate under sub-section (1) of section 5 is issued by the designated authority. Therefore, it would be important to inform the Tribunal that the assessee is availing the VSV Scheme. It is desirable to withdraw the appeal after getting certificate from the designated authority 

Query

AY 2015-16. Appeal filed against assesment order dt 05.12.2017 is pending with CIT(A). Subsequent to filing of appeal rectification orders u/s 154 were passed on 12.02.2018 and 23.03.2020. One out of the rectification order is after 31.01.2020.By both these orders the demand has been reduced.In the instruction to fill Form 1, it has been stated that the date of order cannot be after 31.01.2020.In the above circumstances what will be the disputed tax? How to fill the date of order in Form 1?

Answer

As we understand, The Declarant ought to be given the benefit of the rectification order passed after the specified date under VSVA. Reliance is placed on Question No. 25 of CBDT Circular 9 of 2020 date April 22, 2020 which states that, in a case appeal is pending on the specified date, but a rectification application is also pending with the Ld. A0 which if accepted will reduce the total assessed income. The disputed tax in such cases would be calculated after giving effect to the rectification order passed, if any.  Tax in dispute to be considered after considering the rectification order. 

 

 

Query

AY 2012-13
Tax Paid
Interest Paid
Penalty Levied Rs. 931007
Appeal filed on 26-03-2018
seeking removal of penaty
Part Payment Paid (20%) Rs. 186250 and appeal admiited.
no action till date

Now how much to pay in vivad se vishwas scheme 2020

Answer

The assessee will have to only pay the disputed tax amount under Vivad se Vishwas. The payment made earlier would be adjusted against the tax payable. Interest and Penalty would be waived off.  Please refer Q.No 9 and answer  and Q. No 29 and answer thereon (   F.NO IT(A) 1/ 2020-TPL  Circular  No  9 /2020 dt 22 nd April 2020 )  https://itatonline.org/info/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/CBDT-Circular-9-Vivad-Vishwas.pdf

 

Query

If any order of appeal has been passed after 31.01.2020 by any appellate forum dismissing the appeal or partly allowed, whether the assessee will be eligible under VSV?

Answer

Not .eligible under the scheme . If an appeal is decided ex parte the assessee can make an application for restoration of appeal. When an appeal is restored it relates back  the date of filing ,then an assessee can avail the  benefit of the scheme.

Query

Sir in case we have sufficient amount of brought forward loss and also after reducing the amount to the extent of addition (I.E. WE ACCEPT THE ADDITION MADE BY AO), we have sufficient amount of loss to be carried forward then also whether we are liable to pay tax if we opt for option (II) OF RULE 9

Pls share your View

Answer

If you are in appeal before the Appellate authority , and if desire to settle the issue the assessee has to pay the tax on the disputed amount . Once the tax is penalty will not be levied  and the losses will be allowed to carried forward subject to other conditions .  Please refer question No 53 and answer thereon (  F.NO IT(A) 1/ 2020-TPL  Circular  No  9 /2020 dt 22 nd April 2020 ) https://itatonline.org/info/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/CBDT-Circular-9-Vivad-Vishwas.pdf

Query

Quantum Appeal was pending as on 31/01/2020 Before ITAT. On 20/03/2020 department passed penalty order u/s 271(1)(c). Now if I may apply for Vivad Se Vishwas scheme, can I get immunity for penalty??

Answer

Yes, As per FAQ No. 8 of CBDT Circular 9 of 2020 dated April 22, 2020, If both quantum appeal covering disputed tax and appeal against penalty levied on such disputed tax for an assessment year are pending, the declarant is required to file a declaration form covering both disputed tax appeal and penalty appeal. However, he would be required to pay relevant percentage of disputed tax only. On facts as the Assessing Officer has already passed the penalty order , it is advisable to file an appeal before the CIT (A) on penalty . While filing the form for VVSA  give details of both the appeals .