Mohammed Fakhre Alam Shaikh v. The Assessing Officer. ( Mum) ( Trib) www.itatonline .org

S. 4 : Charge of income-tax – Compensation – Surrender of premises – Allocated flat as compensation to remove illegal occupant – The value of flat received by the assessee as compensation for removing nuisance shall constitute capital receipt – Not taxable. [ S. 2(24),54F, 56(2)(vii)( b )]

The assessee was an illegal occupant of land, who was allotted a flat worth ₹2.59 crores as part of a court settlement after filing a suit against the developer. The AO treated this allotment as taxable income and denied the Section 54F deduction. The assessee argued that the compensation was for surrendering long-occupied premises and thus should be treated as a capital receipt. The ITAT held that the compensation for removing a nuisance is a capital receipt which is outside the scope of section 2(24) and thus the flat’s value was recognised as a non-taxable capital receipt. Relied on  Shri Kishre D.P. v. ITO ( ITA No. 3796/Mum/2014 dt.17-2 -2017 ) (AY. 2018-19) ( ITA No.6153 / Mum/2024    dt. 7-4 -2025  )     (AY.2016 -17 )

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*