This Digest of case laws is prepared by KSA Legal and AIFTP from judgements reported in BCAJ, CTR, DTR, ITD, ITR, ITR (Trib), Chamber's Journal, SOT, Taxman, TTJ, BCAJ, ACAJ, www.itatonline.org and other journals
Click here to download the pdf versions of the Digest of case laws

S.147: Reassessment – Information received in a subsequent assessment year is a valid reason to reopen an assessment for earlier year – Compensation taxable as income from house property [ S.22, 143(1)]

Rak Construction Project Co Pvt Ltd v.ITO ( 2020) The Chamber’s Journal – September -P. 113 ( Mum) (Trib)

S.147: Reassessment – Carry forward and set off losses – Change in the structure of entity from Trust to LLP – Status of an entity incorporated abroad has to be determined even in India according to the law of the Country where the entity was incorporated – Notice to reassessment was quashed [ S. 74, 148 , Art .226 ]

Aberdeen Asia Pacific Including Japan Equity Fund v .DCIT (IT) ( 2020) 191 DTR 1 / 315 CTR 347( Bom) (HC) Aberdeen Emerging Markets Equity Fund v .DCIT (IT) ( 2020) (2020) 191 DTR 1 /315 CTR 347( Bom)(HC) Aberdeen Asia Pacific Excluding Japan Equity Fund v .DCIT (IT) ( 2020) 191 DTR 1/ 315 CTR 347 ( Bom)(HC) Aberdeen Emerging Markets Equity Fund v .DCIT (IT) ( 2020) 191 DTR 1 ( Bom)(HC) Aberdeen Asia Pacific Excluding Japan Equity Fund v .DCIT (IT) ( 2020) 191 DTR 1 ( Bom)(HC)

S.147: Reassessment – After the expiry of four years- Earlier proceedings quashed on technical ground- Fresh notice for reopening and rectifying the error is valid [ S.148, Art, 226 ]

T. Krishnamurthy v .ITO ( 2020) 116 taxmann.com 476/ 195 DTR 33/ 317 CTR 341 / 272 Taxman 80 ( Mad) (HC)

S.147: Reassessment-After the expiry of four years- Failure to deduct tax at source- No failure to disclose material facts – Change of opinion- Reassessment is held to be not valid [ S. 44AB, 148, 194I ]

PCIT v. Bharati Constructions ( 2020) BCAJ- December -P 53 ( Mad ) (HC) PCIT v. URC Construction (P) Ltd ( 2020) BCAJ- December -P 53 ( Mad ) (HC)

S. 145 : Method of accounting – Books of account cannot be rejected merely for non -maintenance of stock register [ S.145(3)

Paramount Impex v. ACIT ( 2020) 117 taxmann.com 802 ( Chd) (Trib)

S. 144C : Reference to dispute resolution panel – Section 144C inserted by the Finance ( No.2) Act , 2009 with retrospective effect from Ist April , 2009 is prospective in nature and would not apply to AY. 2009 -10 or earlier assessment years – Order passed is beyond limitation hence null and void . [ S.143(3) 153(1) ]

Truetzschler India Ltd v DCIT ( 2020) BCAJ- November -P 55 (Mum)(Trib)

S. 143(2) : Assessment – Notice – Appellate Tribunal- Ground on pure question of law can be raised before the ITAT- Notice issued by the ITO who did not have a jurisdiction to issue notice – Statutory notice u/s 143(2) lacks jurisdiction and order is bad in law [ S. 143(3) 254(1) ]

DCIT v. Proficient Commodities Pvt Ltd ( 2020) The Chamber’s Journal -June -P. 82 ( Kol) (Trib)

S. 131 : Power – Discovery – Production of evidence – Summons stating not to depart until permission granted – Violates fundamental rights guaranteed under Part III of the Constitution of India [ S.148, Constitution of India , 1950 Arts, 12 to 35 ]

Sri Naval Kishore Khaitan v. PCIT ( 2020) The Chamber’s Journal-May- P. 86 ( AP) (HC)

S. 115JB : Book profit – Capital gains- Capital asset- Sale of agricultural land- Gains from sale of agricultural land which is not a capital asset cannot be included for computing book profit . [ S.2(14)(iii), 2(IA), 5, 10(1), 45 ]

DCIT v. Motisons Buildtech (P) Ltd ( 2020) 182 ITD 72 /116 taxmann.com 337/ 205 TTJ 484 ( Jaipur) (Trib)/DCIT v. Motisons Entertainment ( P) Ltd (2020) 182 ITD 72/ 205 TTJ 484 (Jaipur) (Trib.) DCIT v. Mitisons Global ( P) Ltd Ltd (2020) 182 ITD 72/ 205 TTJ 484 (Jaipur) (Trib.)

S.68: Cash credits – Gift from father and brother – Agricultural income- Source of deposit explained – Addition is held to be not justified .

Lakadri Naidu v. ITO ( 2020) The Chamber’s Journal – September – P. 112 ( Hyd) (Trib)