Dismissing the appeal of the revenue the Court held that the shares had not been subscribed to by any sister concern or closely related person, but by outsider investors. The methodology adopted was a recognised method of valuation and the Department was unable to show that the assessee adopted a demonstrably wrong approach, or that the method of valuation was made on a wholly erroneous basis, or that it committed a mistake which went to the root of the valuation process. The deletion of addition by the Tribunal is held to be was justified.( AY.2015-16)