The Assessing officer  in the reasons recorded has not mentioned what material facts were not disclosed by the assessee during the course of assessment proceedings and has simply recorded the amount of income which has escaped tax and the department has by affidavit sought to state what material facts were not disclosed which is impermissible. Even if the reasons are taken holistically, what material facts are not disclosed is not pointed out and therefore the notice is liable to be quashed. ( AY. 2012 -13