Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

This section is now closed. Please ask your questions at our new Q&A section
Query asked by Yadhagiri Manku on July 15, 2020

Re: Appeal by ACIT to ITAT after declartion of vivad se viswas scheme

For the Assessment year 2016-17, Assessment has done and order passed by AO with 5 additions made on 30.12.2017.I preferred an appeal to CIT(A) on 02.02.2018. Appeal is partially allowed by CIT(A).out of 5 additions made by AO, 4 additions deleted by CIT(A). Against the rest addition I filed appeal at ITAT later. As appeal is pending at ITAT on 30.01.2020 I filed declaration under vivad se viswas scheme on 28.05.2020. The status showing in the portal is waiting for Form 3. Few days After submission of declaration by me I received letter for hearing from ITAT on 10/07/2020 because of the AO preferred an appeal against the grounds of deletion done by CIT(A).Date of filling appeal by AO is 06.06.2020.
Whether AO can do so even after I filed the vivad se viswas scheme declaration?
If it is yes what are the consequences.
Can I file revised declaration under vivad se viswas scheme again if in case any enhancement done by ITAT as a result of this appeal by AO?

This question is already answered earlier .  According to us ,  when an appeal is decided against the assessee . The department cannot file an  appeal . The Department can file an appeal against a ground held in favour by the CIT(A), if the tax in dispute is more than 50 lalkhs , as per the Circular of the Board  no 3 of 2018 dt 11-07  -2018 ( 2018) 405 ITR 29 (St)   , unless the case falls with exception clause of the Circular No 3 of 2018  dt 20 -08 -2018 (2018) 407 ITR 4 (St)  (Para 10)  The Tribunal has no power of enhancement please refer Mcorp (P) Ltd v CIT ( 2009) 309 ITR 434 (SC).  According to us the declaration is valid . The assessee may write to the  Appellate Tribunal to serve the grounds of appeal of the department . On reading the grounds  the assessee  may be able to decide whether the departmental appeal is valid or not. If the departmental appeal is in accordance with the law , the assessee  may think of contesting the appeal on merit or may also file a separate application under the scheme to settle the departmental appeal by paying the 50% of tax in dispute . Refer Circular F .No IT (A) 1/2020 -TPL No 9 /2020  dt 22 –4 -2020  www.itatonline .org answer to question No 28   . It may not be possible to file the revised form after the passing and servicing of the order by the Appellate Tribunal 

 


 

One comment on “Appeal by ACIT to ITAT after declartion of vivad se viswas scheme
  1. Yaswant Dagliya says:

    Assesee can file application

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*