CIT v. Nicholas Piramil ( India )( Ltd ( Bom)( HC ) www.itatonline .org

S.37(1): Business expenditure – Community development expenditure – Street lights on the road , ambulance for meeting medical emergencies , developing public garden – The concept of business is not static and over a period of time , it would include within its fold the care and concern for the society at large which would result in a good will being created in its favour leading to better business – Allowable as business expenditure .

The Respondent assessee had claimed deduction under the head community development expenditure  for providing  street lights  on the road , ambulance for meeting medical emergencies , developing public garden for residence of the village where the factory is situated . The Assessing Officer disallowed the expenditure on the ground that the same are not incurred wholly and exclusively  for the purpose of  Respondents’ business  . The CIT(A) up held the order the AO. On appeal Tribunal  following the decision in CIT v. Madras Refineries Ltd (2004 )  266 ITR 70 ( Mad)( HC) allowed the appeal on the ground that the concept of business is not static and over a period of time , it would include within its fold the care and concern for the society at large which would result in a good will being created in its favour leading  to better business .  Accordingly  the expenditure is allowed as allowable business expenditure . On appeal by the Revenue the High Court affirmed the order of the Tribunal . (ITA No. 1686 of 2013 dt . 10 -7 2015 )( AY. 1996 -97 )  

One comment on “CIT v. Nicholas Piramil ( India )( Ltd ( Bom)( HC ) www.itatonline .org
  1. G PRABHAKAR says:

    if this decision is followed then all companies can claim corporate Social Responsibility expenditure

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*