ITO v. AMS Trading & Investment (Mum) (Trib)

S. 68 : Cash credits-Share premium and share application-Cross examination was not provided-Confirmation letter, PAN Card, Audited financial statements, bank statement reflecting the transactions, copy of share application form, copy of Form .No 2 filed with the R.O.C. etc-Deletion of addition is affirmed. [S. 132]

The assessee has received the share application money from M/s Empower Industries Ltd and due to search u/s 132 of the Act on the group, the statements were recorded by the investigation wing that they are only providing accommodation entries and no business activity is conducted. The A.O based on the statements recorded in the course of the search of the group, has made addition of share capital including premium in the hands of the assessee and estimated unexplained expenditure. The A.O over looked the various documentary evidences filed by the assessee in support of investments including the confirmation letter, PAN Card, Audited financial statements, bank statement reflecting the transactions, copy of share application form, copy of Form .No 2 filed with the R.O.C. etc. In spite of assessee filing all the details, prima-facie the A.O has not conducted any investigation or enquiry in respect of the information submitted by the assessee and relied only on the information of a third party whose statement was not cross examined or tested. Remand report was called. The assessee prima-facie has complied with the ingredients required u/s 68 of the Act of genuineness, identity and creditworthiness.  The A.O has failed to make further enquiries and relied only on statement of the key person, which was retracted subsequently. (ITA 1863/M/2021 Dt: 25/08/2023)