Dismissing the appeal of the Revenue the Tribunal held that Gifting freebies to dealers and stockists based on performance in meeting sales targets is allowable as a deduction. Circular No 5 of 2012 dt. 18 -2012 prohibits the benefit of freebies directly or indirectly to medical practitioners and their professional associations and not to dealers and stockists . ( ITA . 352 / JPR / 2022 dt .14 -2 -2023 )( AY. 2013 -14 )