This section is now closed. Please ask your questions at our new Q&A section
Answers By Expert: Dr. K. Shivaram (Sr. Advocate)
Query

Please clarify that whether the tax payment under VSVS to be made by 31.10.2021 has to be 110% of whole of disputed tax or on such payment which remained to be on 30.09.2021

Answer

31 -10 -2021 was  Last date for beneficial payment under the VSV Act, 2020 extended by CBDT, vide Notification No.75 of 2021 dated June 25, 2021(2021) 435 ITR (St) 25

Please  refer Circular No 18 /2020 dt 28 -10 -2020 ( 2020 ) 428 ITR 104 (St)  , circular in respect of payment of tax . As per the Circular the declarant can make the payment without additional amount on or before 31 St March , 2021 ( Now extended up to 31-10 -2021 )     Please also refer Circular No 21 /2020 dt 4 -12 -2020. ( 2020 ) 429 ITR 1 ( St)   Q.No. 87 . and Answer state that ,once the required amount of disputed penalty has been paid by the declarant  , interest relating  to such penalty would be waived . The issue being debatable the  declarant may not get the concessional rate as applicable , up to 30-9 -2021 .  In case the Designated levies 110% of the tax in dispute on entire amount the assessee may have to pay 110 % and file the  writ    before  the High Court.   

Query

The assessee had filed their application in Form 1 & 2 in the month of January 2021.
The assessee received Form 3 in Sept 2021 and paid tax on 29.09.2021. But when I fill the payment details I get the message that date of payment can not be prior to the date of filing of Form 1 & 2.
Whether this is due to the problem in the efiling Website?
What should I do for this

Answer

Please write to the Designated Authority  and Chairman CBDT. You may also write to Shri S.R.  Wadhwa  Advocate ,Chairman Representation  committee of the All India Federation of Tax Practioners (AIFTP ) ,who is interacting  with the  Central Board of Direct taxes (CBDT)   on day to day basis as regards  the functioning of portal . His email is , wadwasr@hotmail.com  or aiftpho@gmail.com   

 

 

Query

Sir,
As per Form 3 issued by the CIT, there is no demand and the assessee need not pay any further sum as tax because of TDS Credit already available.

How can I fill Form 4 in the payment particulars. Without filling that section of Form 4, I am unable to file.
Please advise me.

Answer

The assessee may state in the payment particulars the refund due to the assessee and  details of tax deducted at source .  

Query

Sir, I opted for Vivad se Vishwas and filed form 1 and 2 and received form 3. Can we file form 4 before receiving the CIT(A) as proof of withdrawing the appeal . Eventhough I requested for withdrawing the appeal the CIT (A) faceless scheme not responded.
Kindly advise.

Answer

Yes  . Please refer CBDT Circular No. 9 /2020  dt. 22-4 -2020 ,   Q. 43 and answer .  which reads as under “ Under the amended procedure no appeal is required to be withdrawn  before the grant of certificate by DA under section 5. , the appellant is required to withdraw appeal or writ or appeal  pending before the appellant form and submit proof of withdrawal with intimation of payment to the DA as per the same section. Where assessee has made request for withdrawal and such request is under process , proof  of request made shall be enclosed.      

 

 

 

Yes  . Please refer CBDT Circular No. 9 /2020  dt. 22-4 -2020 ,   Q. 43 and answer .  which reads as under “ Under the amended procedure no appeal is required to be withdrawn  before the grant of certificate by DA under section 5. , the appellant is required to withdraw appeal or writ or appeal  pending before the appellant form and submit proof of withdrawal with intimation of payment to the DA as per the same section. Where assessee has made request for withdrawal and such request is under process , proof  of request made shall be enclosed.      

 

 

 

 

Query

We received form 3 from IT department intimating refund. The form 4 was also filed duly. The status as shown in the IT portal is “Awaiting Signed Form 5 from CIT”. In between we have received hearing notice for the appeal u/s 250. How is this possible?

Answer

The assesseee may write to the Office of the CIT (A) informing   that the  assessee  has filed form No 4 and awaiting signed Form 5 under VSV Scheme ,hence the matter may be adjourned . The Assessee may also write to the  Designated Authority to send the Signed Form 5 at the earliest .   

 

 

 

Query

I want to know in which head i have to pay the tax and in which provision (i.e basic,int,fee)

Thankyou

Answer

: It will be regular assessment tax challan , with minor head 400 . Write properly the PAN  NO and Assessment year . There is no separate Challan  has been prescribed .

 

Query

I have received Form 5 on account of settling disputed tax under VSV scheme in Feb 2021. I have received IT Orders and Notices seeking penalty for the same disputed tax. Please advice as to how do I seek a complete solution to this issue

Answer

The assessee  is advised to make an  rectification application  for cancellation of the penalty lived  .The assessee may enclose the  details of payment made as per VSV Scheme. In case the rectification is not done with in the limitation period of filing an appeal before the CIT (A) the assessee is advised to  file an appeal before   the CIT (A) on merit as well as on legal issue .  

 

Query

What if the payment to be made under the Scheme after the receipt of Form 3 is not paid within the due date given for payment along with additional amount(i.e Oct 31st 2021)
Will the appeal already filed hold good or will the appeal be treated as withdrawn and revert back to assessment proceedings

Answer

Appeal will hold good only the immunity under VSV Scheme is not available to the assessee.  Please refer Circular No 9/2020   dt.22-4 -2020 ,    Q. 49 . Once declaration is filed under Vivad Se Vishwas and for financial difficulties ,payment is not made accordingly , will the declaration be null and void ? Answer: Yes it would be void .  

Query

Amount Payable under Form-1 filed by me was Rs. 1,89,846 and Rs. 2,08,831 (10% extra option). Department issued Form-3 and amount payable was Rs.2,37,811 and Rs. 2,56,794 (10% extra).

Later on they corrected suo moto due to clarification regarding 125% applicability and Amount payable was shown as Rs. 1,90,350 and Rs. 2,09,385 (10% extra).

Due to error on the Income Tax Portal we were not able to download Form-3 till 30/09/2021. We had spoken several time with the helpline numbers. At last it was downloaded on 7th October,2021.

My client had paid Rs. 1,89,846 before 30th September,2021 as per Form-1. Form-3 came later on.

Now my query is how much additional amount my client will have to pay :

1) Rs. 504 (Difference of Form-1 and Form-3) OR

2) Rs.554 (Difference of Form-1 and Form-3 – Rs. 504 plus Rs. 50 (10% extra) OR

3) Rs. 19539 (Difference of Rs. 209385 (Total Additional Amount as per Form-3) – Rs. 189846 (Amount Paid)

Please guide. This situation has arisen due to Departmental Portal issue without any fault of the Client

Answer

The tax has to be  paid as per the provisions of the Act . The tax consultant may be able to guide on verification of records . The assessee may write to the Designated Authority and  Chairman CBDT. The     Assessee may also send the copy of letter addressed to the Designated Authority  to grievance cell of  assessee’s jurisdiction .   The Grievance Cell has to action with in 21 days  of receipt of the petition .  The Procedure  for Grievance Redressal is published in the website of the CBDT .    The assessee  may also write to Shri S.R.  Wadhwa  Advocate ,Chairman Representation  committee of the All India Federation of Tax Practioners (AIFTP ) ,who is interacting  with the  Central Board of Direct taxes (CBDT)   on day to day basis as regards  the functioning of portal . His email is , wadwasr@hotmail.com  or aiftpho@gmail.com   

  

Query

What is the time limitation for issue of refund by the department determined in Form 5 of VSV? If the refund is not received within the said time limit then whether the assessee is entitled for interest on the delayed period and what is the procedure. pl. guide

Answer

There is neither  time prescribed under the Act nor interest is payable to  the assessee.  The assessee may make an request in writing  to the Designated Authority  to grant the refund with interest at the earliest . If no response is received   within reasonable time  the assessee may file writ before the High Court. High Court has the power to direct the  Designated Authority/ Assessing Officer  to grant refund along with the interest .