Pankajbhai Jaysukhlal Shah v. ACIT ( 2019 ) 110 taxmann.com 51 / (2020) 425 ITR 70/ 312 CTR 300/ 185 DTR 306(Guj)(HC), www.itatonline.orgEdiitorial : SLP of revenue is dismissed ,ACIT v. Pankajbhai Jaysukhlal Shah ( 2020 ) 275 Taxman 99 ( SC)

S. 148 : Reassessment-The officer recording the reasons and the officer issuing notice has to be the same person-Any inherent defect therein cannot be cured -The fact that the assessee participated in the proceedings is irrelevant. [S. 147, 148(2), 292B]

Allowing the petition the Court held that the officer recording the reasons u/s 148(2) for reopening the assessment & the officer issuing notice u/s 148(1) has to be the same person- If the reasons are recorded by the DCIT but the notice is issued by the ITO, the reassessment proceedings are invalid. The s. 148 notice is a jurisdictional notice. Any inherent defect therein cannot be cured u/s 292B. The fact that the assessee participated in the proceedings is irrelevant. Accordingly the notice issued u/s. 148 and all proceedings pursuant thereto including the assessment order are quashed. (CA. No. 230 of 2019, dt. 09.04.2019) (AY.2011-12)