Answers By Expert: Advocate C.B.Thakar
  about composition scheme for manufacturer
whether a pan masala and tobacco trader who assemble pan on its own then does it amounts to manufacturing of pan masala or it is amounts to trading of pan masala  


► Read Answer

  Composition scheme
Composition scheme for kirana store as 1% to be paid on Tax Free goods also as rice dal wheat.


► Read Answer

  Input tax credit of GST on the car taken on lease
Assessee is an individual  engaged in business of trading and registered under GST  , the has taken the High Value Car on lease for 10 years , whether he can claim the credit of GST paid on lease rentals .


► Read Answer

  Value of land in sale of Under construction flat under GST
Assessee is a developer and engaged in the business of developing of real estate project. He has calculated the GST liability on sale of  under construction flats as per agreement to sale with flat purchaser by taking deduction of 1/3 of the consideration . In the GST Audit , departments is denying the deduction for 1/3 for the land on the ground that there is no involvement of share  transfer of land in the agreement to sale and land is transferred only when the sale agreement is executed with the society . Is the interpretation of the GST audit department…


► Read Answer

  GST ON EDC AND IDC ACCOUNT IN AN UNDER CONSTRUCTION BUILDING
KINDLY ADVISE IF THE GST IS PAYABLE ON EDC AND IDC ACCOUNT IN  AN UNDER CONSTRUCTION BUILDING. IF SO, WHAT IS THE RATE OF GST PAYABLE AND FROM WHICH DATE THE GST IS APPLICABLE AS THE BUILDER IS DEMANDING THE GST AFTER GIVING THE POSSESSION OF THE APARTMENT AND JUST BEFORE THE REGISTRY OF THE PROPERTY.


► Read Answer

  RCM on ocean freight
RCM on ocean freight was struck down by Supreme court in Mohit Mineral"s case. However notifcation exempting RCM on Ocean freight was made effective from 1st October 2023. Does this mean that RCM is payable till 30th Sepember 2023 ?


► Read Answer

  Is GST applicable on Google Adsense income?
Sir, I am a YouTuber based in Ahmedabad. I have a channel on YouTube where I make videos on various topics. I also have a blog where I write articles. I have monetized the channel and blog with Google Adsense.i expect my annual earning in FY 2023-24 from AdSense to exceed Rs 20 Lakhs. All income is received from Singapore. The income is offered to income-tax under the head "business profits". I read an article in Tax Guru that as the AdSense income is received from Singapore, it constitutes "export of services" and is not liable for payment of GST.…


► Read Answer

  GST Applicability on corporate Guarantee
what will be the GST amount Chargeable on the amount of Corporate Guarantee in case of newly opened Subsidiary Company?


► Read Answer

  Authority of State Tax Officer on matter related to CGST
A person is registered under GST Act falling under the jurisdiction of Central Tax Officer. Business  of the registered person has been inspected u/s 67 (1) of the SGST Act by the State Tax Officer, the goods has been seized and the proceedings has been further initiated u/s 74. Is the action by State Tax Officer legal? Do the State Tax Officer have authority  to inspect as well as initiate a proceeding in the matter of a registered person falling under the jurisdiction of Central tax Officer?


► Read Answer

  GST ITC
Sir, in our case supplier is not filed by GSTR-1 in time for the financial year  2020-21 but buyer clime the GST ITC based on tax invoice,   the same point is raised  department issued a  notice required a clarification of  excess  declared  GST ITC between the GSTR-3B  vs GSTR-2B  . The above difference GST ITC  is payable  complosory  ? if any judgement declared by courts please forward  judgement


► Read Answer