Question And Answer | |
---|---|
Subject: | Income Tax Liability on ESOP |
Category: | Income-Tax |
Querist: | CA Govind Agrawal |
Answered by: | Advocate Shashi Ashok Bekal |
Tags: | ESOP |
Date: | August 9, 2022 |
Background
Company A is headquartered in US and has a subsidiary company B in India.
Company A is primarily owned by a Private Equity firm (approx. 80% ownership)
Company A (US company) has issued ESOP to employees including employees of subsidiary company in India. Stock options were issued at a price of $10 per option.
FMV as per merchant banker report is $15 as on December 31, 2020
In June 2021, there is transfer of ownership to a new Private Equity company. Both are large PE firms and majority stake exceeding 70-75% has exchanged hands
As per transaction price for above deal is approx. $30
Company A has not obtained any valuation report as on date after that Dec 20
As part of the ownership transfer, ESOPs issued by company A were cancelled and the employees (including Indian employees) were paid the net differential value ($30 less $10 = $20)
Query
Query is specifically around tax treatment in the hands of Indian employees. Company has shown this in form16 under other income.
· Whether the options granted by company A under its ESOP plan (and later on rescinded by the employees) are treated as capital asset?
· If answer to question 1 is affirmative, then whether the waiver of right to receive shares by the employees amount to transfer chargeable to tax under the head “ capital gains”?
· If answer to question 2 is affirmative, then can the period of holding of these options for computation of capital gains be considered from the grant date of such ESOP options?
The terms of cancellation of ESOPS would have to be understood. Extinguishment of rights or buyback of shares would be a transfer as per the scheme of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
Waiver of right to receive would be a transfer and the same would attract Capital Gains tax. The period of holding would be from the period from the grant date of such ESOP options.